Ask a founder why customers should choose their product, and the answer usually arrives as a list. Faster setup, better support, flexible pricing, strong security, a clean interface, an integration for everything. Each item is true, but together they are the reason buyers cannot tell the product apart from the next one.
In Part 1 you chose the frame, the set of alternatives buyers will compare you with. This post covers the second decision: the claim you lead with inside that frame.
The most useful research I know on this is a 2006 Harvard Business Review article by James Anderson, James Narus and Wouter van Rossum, Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets. They sorted the ways suppliers state value into three types:
• All benefits: list everything the offering might deliver. The pitfall is benefit assertion, which claims value without showing it. Many of the benefits also match what the next best alternative offers, so the supplier ends up looking more similar, not less.
• Favorable points of difference: list where you beat the next best alternative. The pitfall is value presumption, which means assuming a difference matters to the buyer because it favors you.
• Resonating focus: pick the one or two differences, and perhaps one point of parity, that deliver the most value to the customer. This is the approach the authors recommend. It requires customer research, because you cannot know which difference matters without it.
Dunford's method gives a way to turn a difference into a claim in three steps, in this order:
• Attribute: Name a capability the product has that the alternatives in your chosen frame do not, or do not provide in the same way. “We have an approval workflow” is an attribute, but it only becomes a difference when compared with the options buyers actually use.
• Value: Explain what that capability lets the customer do, avoid, or improve in terms they care about. The value should not be a feature described in more enthusiastic language; it should be the practical consequence of using the feature.
• Proof: Show the evidence a skeptical buyer would accept. Depending on the claim, that might be measured time saved, a before-and-after result, an implementation record, a customer reference, or a demonstration of how the product works.
Here is a hypothetical for the contract product from Part 1:
• Attribute: a library of Legal-approved answers that reps can use during a deal.
• Value: reps get answers to routine questions in minutes, and Legal keeps control of what is said.
• Proof: turnaround time on routine questions before and after, from pilot customers, plus a statement from a customer's head of Legal.
TrustRadius’s 2026 B2B buyer research is useful here, with an important caveat: TrustRadius is a software review platform, so its research is vendor-produced rather than an independent industry census. The company says it surveyed 1,862 technology buyers and 444 technology vendors in January 2026. Among the findings, 83% of buyers shortlisted three or fewer products, 79% had heard of the product they ultimately bought before beginning research, and 74% used peer reviews to inform a purchase.
These figures do not prove that one particular headline will increase conversion, and the survey’s commercial context should be kept in mind. They do point to two practical realities: buyers often begin with a short list, and they seek evidence beyond the claims a vendor makes about itself. Awareness can help a product get considered; credible proof helps buyers assess whether the promise holds up.
That is why proof should be tied to the claim, not added as decoration. If the claim is speed, show the time saved. If it is reduced manual work, show which steps disappear. If it is control, explain the mechanism that preserves it. A row of customer logos may establish that other companies use the product, but it does not automatically explain why a buyer should choose it over an alternative.
Here is a practical way to hold both views when you choose a claim. A real difference that buyers value and that you can prove deserves to lead. Where the products in your frame are close to interchangeable, the claim has to work harder at being specific and memorable, and at tying you to the situation that starts a search. Either way, a claim that fails both the "does it matter" check and the "can you prove it" check is not worth leading with.
Choosing one lead claim means deciding what you stop saying. Sort every claim on your site, deck and sales script into three piles:
• Parity: benefits buyers expect from everyone in the category. Keep them where buyers need reassurance, but do not present them as your main reason to choose you.
• Unproven: claims for which you cannot currently provide credible evidence. Hold them back until you can substantiate them.
• Unvalued: differences that are real and provable but do not carry much weight in the buying decision. Keep them only if they help explain the product or serve a specific audience.
What remains is a short list. Pick one lead claim and, if you need it, one supporting claim. That is your resonating focus.
A long list gets repeated as a long list. Sales, marketing and your own pitch each end up emphasizing different strengths, and buyers hear three companies. One lead claim gives everyone the same sentence. Unproven claims cost trust that is hard to rebuild. If the TrustRadius numbers are even roughly right for your buyers, more than half will discount anything you cannot back up. A single claim also gives your roadmap a test. For any feature or fix, you can ask whether it makes the claim more true or easier to prove. And it is cheaper. Saying less takes fewer assets, fewer sales slides and less training.
List everything you currently claim, sort it into the three piles then pick the lead claim, write its ladder, and go through the cut list exercise. Part 3 covers who the claim is for, and how to write the position and lock it.
If you want a second opinion on your lead claim, get in touch and tell me what you are weighing.
Here is a free Positioning Score Tool to help you with your positioning exercise.